Someone fills in your contact form, the site says “thank you,” and then the email never shows up. It’s one of the most common website problems, and it’s rarely the form itself. Usually the form worked fine and the email notification is what went missing. Here’s what to check, in order.

First, check whether the submission was saved

Most form tools keep a copy of every submission inside your website dashboard, often under the form’s Entries. Log in and look there before anything else.

  • If the entry is there, you haven’t lost the lead. The form works, and the problem is email delivery. Keep reading.
  • If there’s no entry, the form itself may be failing, or its spam protection may be blocking real people. That one usually needs your web developer.

What to check, in order

  1. Your spam and other folders. Check spam or junk, Gmail’s Promotions and Updates tabs, and Outlook’s Other tab. Also check whether an inbox rule or filter is moving these messages somewhere. If your business email has an administrator, they can also check the quarantine, where suspicious messages are held before they reach anyone.
  2. The recipient address. Open the form’s notification settings and read the “send to” address carefully. Typos are common, and so are addresses for someone who has left, a mailbox that was deleted, or a mailbox that’s full.
  3. Whether notifications are switched on. A notification can be turned off by accident when a form is edited. Some forms also have routing rules that send the email to different people depending on how a visitor answers, so make sure the rules still match your team.
  4. Who the email says it’s from. Many forms are set up to send the notification “from” the visitor’s own address, so you can just hit reply. The trouble is that your website isn’t allowed to send email as someone’s Gmail or work address. To an inbox, that looks exactly like a forged message, so it gets filtered or rejected. The fix is to send from an address on your own domain, like [email protected], and put the visitor’s address in the Reply-To field. Replying still goes straight to them.
  5. Whether your website’s email is authenticated. Out of the box, many websites, WordPress included, send email straight from the web server with no proof that the server is allowed to send for your domain. Inboxes increasingly treat that as suspicious. The fix is to send your site’s email through a proper email service using SMTP (the standard way email servers hand messages to each other), and to add that service to your domain’s SPF and DKIM records. Those are the settings that tell inboxes which services can send email for you.
  6. Your own email system. Sometimes it’s your own mail security that’s blocking the message, for example a strict DMARC policy (another domain email setting) or an admin spam filter that doesn’t recognize the website as a trusted sender.

Steps 1 to 3 are usually things you can check yourself. Steps 4 to 6 involve your form settings, your website, and your domain’s DNS, so they’re often a job for whoever manages your website and email.

How to test it

  1. Fill in the form on your live site using a different address from the one that receives notifications, such as a personal Gmail account.
  2. Confirm the entry appears in your website dashboard.
  3. Check the receiving inbox, including spam, for the notification.
  4. If it arrives in a Gmail inbox, open it, click the three-dot menu, and choose Show original. You want PASS next to SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.

Test again after anything changes: a new email provider, a website update, a DNS change, or someone joining or leaving your team.

Don’t rely on email alone

Even when everything is set up correctly, email can be delayed or filtered, and delivery is never guaranteed. A few habits keep leads from slipping through:

  • Check your form entries in the dashboard every so often, not just your inbox.
  • Send notifications to a shared address, like info@, that reaches more than one person, so a vacation or a departure doesn’t strand them.
  • For anything business-critical, like orders, bookings, or high-value leads, consider sending submissions straight into a CRM or a dedicated email service as well.

Related guides: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC explained: what they are and whether you need them · Editing your forms

If you’re a GORGEOUS client, open a ticket and we’ll track down where your form emails are going. Not a client yet? Get in touch.

Still stuck?

Two easy ways to reach us: open a ticket and a real person on our team picks it up, or click "Help & Support" right inside your dashboard.

Open a ticket